Dhia Aldoori

Dhia Aldoori
Autumn 2011 in Ohio

Sunday, April 20, 2008

Chapter 3: Good Nutrition

Opinion: Too much influence on medical decision-making comes from the pharmaceutical industry. …… Too much inherent conflict of interests.
(Revision changes are in orange, and revision dates are at the end of the chapter).

The mainstay of good nutrition is intake in appropriate quantities the following:
• Amino acids in general, and essential amino acids in particular.
• Vitamins and minerals.
• Water.
• Sufficient fat.
• An energy source of either fat or carbohydrate.
• Roughage, vegetables and fruits.and fruits.
The first three are relatively easy to explain, but the others are more complicated.

Amino Acids and Essential Amino Acids.
The amino acids are those substances present in proteinous foods such as fish, chicken, turkey, eggs, dairy products, etc. When we eat such foods they will be digested into the body as amino acids. The amino acids are absolutely essential for building most body tissues and can be used indirectly as an energy source after being transformed into glucose. They are also necessary for making hormones and enzymes. These last two: hormones and enzymes are substances that control the production of other tissues, organs, life rhythms and energy production from different biological fuels.
To illustrate the tie in between protein (amino acids) and tissue formation it is easy to understand that unless there is protein intake there can't be formation of muscle. The last is formed mostly out of protein itself, so without the building blocks there is no building.
Another illustration of the role of amino acids is formation of hormones, which have effects on other organs to enable their function. Amino acids are the precursors (raw materials) for many different hormones. An example is tryptophan which is an amino acid present in many animal and plant proteins, in the body is transformed into 5-HTP and then into serotonin and to a controlled degree into melatonin. The last is an important hormone necessary for promoting natural sleep. And so on for almost every hormone in the body.
The next question is: how much is necessary to sustain health? The current recommendation is an intake of 0.8 gm of protein per kilogram body weight per day for adults. I think that number should be at least that much to ensure prevention of illnesses like coronary artery disease, common migraines and fibromyalgia/chronic fatigue syndrome. This statement will be clarified in later chapters. I am comfortable with the 45 grams of protein present in 170 grams of canned tuna fish (equivalent to the 6 ounce can of tuna fish) per day. This probably will provide less than what is required by a 70-kilo (154 pound) adult, but I believe the remainder of a person’s food intake will make up the rest of the necessary protein.

Vitamins and minerals.

Much ado is made about vitamins and I think justifiably so. Vitamins are necessary substances for our health which allow and promote building of our tissues, utilization of different fuels in energy production, efficient functioning of cells in our body and protection against cancer.
The recommended dietary allowances of current day are levels below which illness may happen. Given the way these levels were arrived at I don’t believe they are applicable to all different age groups. Additionally the needs vary a lot with what kind of nutrition is being consumed. For example the more carbohydrate intake the higher would be the need for vitamin B1.
A special situation applies to two vitamins. This situation concerns their difficulty in gaining entry into the body. The two vitamins I am talking about are vitamin B-12 (cyanocobalamin) and vitamin B-1 (thiamin). Both of these vitamins are water-soluble but to get absorbed via the gastrointestinal tract requires complicated processes, which are energy dependent and they are not absorbed with ease. Also vitamin B-12 requires the availability of other locally produced substances. In other words their entry into the body isn't as easy as you might assume. Hence with aging or becoming unhealthy the amount or route of intake would have to change. My advice is to get those two vitamins by injection from age 35 and on. The vitamin B-12 (cyanocobalamin) form which dissolves under the tongue looks promising.
To ensure a sufficient intake of vitamins my advice in addition to above is to take as follows:

-Copper 2 mg daily (NOT acceptable in a multivitamin, and don't take on an empty stomach) [more to follow].
-Vitamin C 100 - 250 mg daily (acceptable in a good quality multivitamin)
-Vitamin A 4000 units daily (acceptable in a good quality multivitamin)
-Folic acid 0.4 mg up to 1 mg daily (acceptable in a good quality multivitamin)
-Calcium 500 mg + vit D (100 to 200 units) twice to thrice daily
-Multivitamin tablet one daily
-Vitamin B-12 (cyanocobalamin) 250 mcg daily [if not taking it by injection or sublingually] – I prefer the injection modality once a month or even less frequently.
-Vitamin B-1 100 mg daily [if not taking it by injection – again I prefer the latter]
-Niacin 100-250 mg daily [this frequently will cause hot flushing and itchiness of face and ears until the body becomes accustomed to it. Taking it with a meal lessens this side effect.] (acceptable in a good quality multivitamin)
(Since initial publishing I have revamped a couple of things and changed the quantities).

The vitamin A, I believe plays a role in prevention of cancer in general but not against any specific form of cancer. The folic acid participates in a major way in prevention of coronary artery disease. The calcium and vitamin D are necessary for bones and functioning of many other tissues such as muscles and nervous tissue. The multivitamin tablet is to blanket cover the body’s needs. The vitamin B-12 (cyanocobalamin) is essential for energy, nervous system function and heart disease prevention. The vitamin B-1 is essential especially for energy production and nervous system function.
There are many other vitamins and minerals, which I think, are sufficiently provided for by our nutrition. This opinion can change if more facts concerning them come to my attention.
On the other hand I think the importance of vitamin E is overrated and the same for vitamin C (but both have high merit when taken in reasonable quantities). A word of [13] caution about vitamin C is that when you take a more than necessary amount regularly and you stop taking it suddenly, you will feel tired or even depressed.
Another word of caution concerning taking vitamins or minerals more than indicated can be dangerous, as in the case of vitamin A and D. The entire mentioned above is for adults. Please consult with your doctor before using any of them.

Water.
Many texts and dietary regimens promote the intake of water in formidable quantities. I agree with a good intake of water always. This agreement is based on the importance of water in all bodily functions and just by knowing that the body content is around 65% by weight you can surmise that water has to be available to a person in order to stay healthy.
The only advisory comment I will make here is to take in enough water (or other fluids), which will make the color of the urine off white or very light yellow. When that color has been attained in a normal person that should indicate a healthy level of hydration in the body. There are conditions, which can be harmed by too much fluid intake. Please consult with your doctor.

Sufficient fat.
I believe a certain minimum of fat is necessary to preserve health. The rationale behind this is that there are many vitamins that require fat to be present in our diets to enable their absorption from our gastrointestinal systems. These vitamins are necessary as I described briefly above. This minimum fat intake, I believe should be above 30 % of daily calorie intake. Fortification of this belief is for example the lower the fat intake the higher the incidence of breast cancer in adult females, and vice versa the higher the fat intake the less the incidence of breast cancer. Another example is the incidence of stomach cancer in Japan, which is markedly high. Their fat intake averages about 11% of their daily calorie intake.
On the other hand the fear of fat intake causing heart disease is pretty much unfounded when scrutinized closely. Most studies that have designated fat intake to be dangerous to the heart and/or lead to elevated cholesterol don’t look at the calorie intake at the same time. Looking at the caloric total is of the utmost importance in deciding on importance of different food elements for the heart. When the calorie content is examined in relation to cholesterol levels in the blood and other indices of health in the blood, all of the indicators point without doubt toward a higher proportional fat intake being better for the heart and cholesterol levels. That would be in comparison to a high carbohydrate diet of equal caloric content.
Another highly important issue to look at within this context is that there are two glaring examples where high fat intake (even the saturated form) is associated with lower myocardial infarction rates compared to low fat intake than the rest of the studied world with the exception of Japan. The first one is that of France where they intake approximately 43% of their calorie intake as saturated fat but they have six times less heart attacks than that of the United States. The latter takes in about 37% fat calorie wise in their diets. The example I like to quote most often though is that of the Eskimos. They take in around 47% saturated fat daily plus approximately 900 mg of cholesterol daily (the recommended amount in the USA is less than 300 mg per day). They have no heart attacks at all. This holds true only when they ingest their traditional diets. When they move to other westernized cultures and partake of the local diets they start getting heart attacks as frequently as the local population. Note to doctors – therefore genetics are not the explanation for the phenomenon observed in the Eskimos.

An energy source of either fat or carbohydrate.
Fat is an excellent source of energy. Any bodily function, which requires a sustained supply of energy, is usually dependent on fatty acids (fat). That includes the beating of the heart and sustained muscular activity of the limbs and torso. The muscular activity of the respiratory muscles also depends significantly on fat. Even by numbers the amount of calories present in fat per weight exceeds that of carbohydrates and proteins.
On the other hand I don’t think carbohydrates pose any threat to health as long as their intake doesn’t exceed their utilization as a fuel in an ongoing way. However if we have an excess of carbohydrates then what isn't used quickly will be forced inside cells and some amounts of glycogen are formed and stored in certain cells and the remainder will be transformed into triglycerides and thence stored fat and cholesterol. Ultimately we will result in higher levels of cholesterol also. Another drawback of excess carbohydrates then it will signal negatively to the adrenal glands and in effect “tell it to take a rest and don’t produce adrenalin because the body has a sufficient energy supply”. Continued excess of carbohydrates will ultimately result in diabetes mellitus type 2 (more later).
My preference for health reasons would be fat. I would hesitate with this opinion if the fat is of animal origin in countries that allow their animals to be injected with growth hormones.

Roughage, vegetables and fruit.
The necessity of roughage and fiber in our diets stands to reason just merely by the fact that the nutrition of our forefathers during certain seasons contained a high amount of such. The actual tie in as to how it is good for our health isn't clear to me yet. Statistical data would seem to support its importance at this point. But statistics are statistics and they aren't definitive scientific proof.
So my current advice would be to have enough roughage and fiber in our diets to allow a comfortable bowel motion once daily.
Concerning fruits and vegetables they are an important part of our diet with very important constituents in them. They have different powers and benefits and only now are coming to light. Suffice it to say at this time that daily consumption of fruits and vegetables are very important for health maintenance. The question of how much to consume I will leave alone for now.
On the other hand I think relying on vegetables alone isn't healthy. The reason I say that is I believe it becomes too difficult to obtain sufficient protein that way. Additionally there will be an absence of vitamin B12, which isn't available in plant products.
To cap things off about nutrition I would like to say something about the number of meals one should take per day. I don’t think a fixed number for all human beings apply. I do believe it to be essential that a person should try and be regular in their eating habits. Regular in timing and number of meals. This will enable the body to have another rhythm promoting factor available to get the body in a stable biological rhythm. This number could be 1-3 depending on the person’s energy expenditure and what they eat. The previous and current advice of eating a good breakfast, having a midday meal and then a supper (which by the way I used to think was true), I think is incorrect and doesn’t apply to all human beings by any means.

_______________________________________
Revision to this chapter November 27, 2009

15 comments:

  1. A question or two by indigo40:

    Peanut butter: Most peanut butters in the United States markets have added sugars in them. This sugar will stimulate increased secretion of insulin, which inhibits the secretion of adrenaline. Adrenaline is absolutely necessary for health. Additionally, secretion of insulin leads to storage of sugar, mostly in the form of fats (mainly triglycerides) and generally this is undesirable. An option here would be natural or organic peanut butters and add saccharine and salt to them to taste. (I do one sacket of saccharine with one quarter teaspoon of salt per 16 ounces of peanut butter.)

    Coffee and tea: the main component, which is talked about here is the caffeine. Caffeine when taken in moderate amounts can increase attentiveness, energy, and even mood. That being said, excessive intake can cause restlessness, insomnia, and even a hallucinatory state (I have witnessed this in one young lady who had taken caffeine pills, ill advisedly). As far as an impact on the heart or hypertension, I have heard rumors. But no real evidence to date. Another component of coffee and tea is tannic acid. This substance may lead to dyspepsia. Therefore those with sensitive stomachs should beware especially when drinking said beverage on an empty stomach. To summarize, I would say one or 2 cups per day, more than four hours before bedtime should be okay. A little note here is that if a person is used to a certain amount of coffee and tea and stops taking that altogether, they will most likely develop a headache within 48 to 72 hours or less, and feel somewhat tired. This usually subsides within a few days. The cause is the dependence that has resulted from the regular intake of caffeine.

    Artificial sweeteners: one to two sackets of saccharine (Sweet Lo ) per day is probably okay. Sucralose (Splenda), I am not comfortable with yet. The discomfort here is because they have taken a sucrose molecule and transformed it so as not to be absorbed. I am not sure that is safe. Once it has been out a few more years then I may be okay with it. Aspartame has many questions swirling around it, and I personally tend to avoid. Sorbitol structurally seems safe enough, but too much of it, causes diarrhea.

    Cheese and yogurt: as long as these two products are devoid of preservatives, and bovine growth hormone then I am comfortable with their intake without limit. That is in spite of their content of saturated fat, which as I have said elsewhere (Chapter 7), I believe has no bearing on development of atherosclerosis. And unless taken relatively excessively should not lead to weight gain either, as on the contrary, they probably lead to body fat loss, with a counter gain of muscle and bone mass. In fact, the French take in saturated fat in their diet to the tune of 43%, but still have six times less heart attacks than the United States does. This phenomenon is called the French Paradox [Keys A (ed) Coronary heart disease in seven countries. Circulation 1970 (Suppl to vol.41) 1-211.]. And no I don't think it's the antioxidant impact of red wine. Here it is more likely to be other factors.

    Dr. Aldoori

    ReplyDelete
  2. B12 deficiency and MS symptoms

    Vitamin B12 deficiency is estimated to affect 10%-15% of individuals over the age of 60.

    A recent study in Israel of elderly hospitalized patients found 40% had low or borderline serum B12 levels. Vegetarians are another group with inadequate dietary B12 intake since much of our B12 comes from meat consumption. A recent study showed 50% of long term vegetarians have B12 deficiency, with decreased serum B12 levels and elevated homocysteine levels.

    Vitamin B12 deficiency can cause unusual neurological symptoms such as tremor, gait disturbance, severe pain, and can mimic MS (multiple sclerosis) or even Parkinson’s Syndrome. The physical signs and symptoms can often mimic other diseases and the diagnosis is frequently missed.

    An excellent book on the topic is: Could it Be B12? An Epidemic of Misdiagnosis by Sally M. Pacholok, R.N. and Jeffrey J Stuart, D.O.

    Most doctors do not test for B12, and even they do a blood test, they do the standard serum B12 which is unreliable. A more accurate test called the methyl malonate test has been devised.

    The substance, Methyl Malonate is elevated in the urine and serum in patients with B12 deficiency.

    Should the B12 level be low in spite of oral or sublingual B12 supplements, then inexpensive B12 injections can be taken at home. Recent work by Kuzminski showed that daily 2 mg. oral B12 serves as well as monthly 1 mg intramuscular B12 injections.

    Other tip offs: Serum Homocysteine is elevated in B12 deficiency. And red blood cell size (MCV) is enlarged.

    It is important to discover B12 deficiency early, since nerve damage can be irreversible if not discovered right away.

    B12 Deficiency by Jeffrey Dach MD

    Jeffrey Dach MD
    4700 Sheridan Suite T
    Hollywood Fl 33021
    954-983-1443
    Web Site Jeffrey Dach MD
    Natural Medicine 101

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree with everything that Dr. Dach is saying here especially I like emphasizing his point where we should not rely on the serum levels of B12. There is one minor difference in my approach to dealing with B12 issues. Specifically I don't want to wait until I have evidence of there being a deficiency. Pre-empt and prevent the deficiency from happening at all. B12 is available, it is cheap, it is safe, and will help prevent heart disease, neurological disease, and blood disease. So why wait before starting it?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Questions About Fats or Healthy Oils, Total Caloric Intake

    It is clear that fats/healthy oils must be present in the intestinal tract in order for certain vitamins to be absorbed. In my instance, the prescription is for Vitamin D. The question is this - how MUCH oil needs to be ingested for this process to occur? Does tossing some whole wheat pasta in a tablespoon of olive oil do the job? Will a flax seed or fish oil capsule work? I have long since trained myself to stay away from things like fried chicken which, although I love it, is higher in calories than I can consume.

    Any specifics on amount of oils or fats required for absorption would be appreciated.

    Second question is this – for a 58-year-old woman who is more than 50 lbs. overweight, and who is now getting some daily physical exercise (walking, light aerobics and light toning classes), what should target total caloric intake be?

    ReplyDelete
  5. To Anonymous:
    These are wonderful, highly intelligent questions which I would like to answer scientifically and in depth. Give me a few days please.

    ReplyDelete
  6. To Anonymous:
    Your answers are at this link -
    http://thepillarsofhealth.blogspot.com/2011/11/how-much-fat-to-eat-to-absorb-vitamin-d.html

    ReplyDelete
  7. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Dear Dr. Aldoori,

    Hope you are doing well. It's been an absolute pleasure being your patient so far! I plan on coming for another appointment this upcoming summer upon graduation at school.

    In the meantime, I was wondering if you could possibly answer a few questions when you get some free time. Thanks so much in advance for answering any of them!

    1) What is the importance of taking copper? Should everyone be taking 2mg of this supplement daily, separate from a multivitamin? Or does this apply only to a specific group of individuals? Also, is there an advantage to taking either the citrate or glycinate form in terms of absorption?

    2) You recently stressed that I need to increase the levels of GABA in my body to help with my persistent anxiety. Are there natural ways to do this through specific foods or even drinks, such as loose leaf tea (due to its precursor l-theanine)?

    3) I know that your diet has worked wonderfully for me! That is when I have stuck to it. Last semester, I successfully dropped from 203 to 185 while following it, but recently went back up to 190 after reintroducing carbs into my diet.

    I realize that the weight number isn’t so important, but achieving health is. I am still seeking to eliminate a large amount of visceral fat I have around my entire midsection area. After doing some further research I noticed that Dr. Atkins suggested completely eliminating fruits and keeping total net carbs below 20mg daily for his induction phase in order to reach a state of ketosis. I like the fact that you advocate the consumption of unlimited veggies and fruit for desert a couple times a day.

    I was wondering if by following your diet of mainly high protein, high fat (the good kinds), and low carbs, in addition to fruit and vegetables if I have lost weight due to a similar process of ketosis, just not to the degree of those who follow Atkins? Is ketosis dangerous? Of course I want to lose weight, but would not dare to compromise my health while doing it. I am still trying to get 10,000 steps in per day, but this is often very difficult to do while in school and especially near the end of the semester.

    In following the low-carb aspect of the diet, I know I should not consume bread, pasta, rice, pastries of any kind, and even potatoes, but what about higher starch veggies like corn, carrots, and sweet potatoes, or even food like oatmeal? What about high sugar fruits people often talk about like bananas and grapes? Do these fruits and veggies trigger high levels of insulin which then puts the body in fat storing mode?

    4) Do you think that coffee or tea (loose leaf) is healthier to drink? I am currently consuming about two mugs of coffee a day (~400mg caffeine), but also drink loose leaf tea a few times a week now. When I did drink tea everyday a year back it helped me in fully eliminating cavities. However, I have worried about consuming too much fluoride, aluminum, and possible iron absorption interference from drinking too much of it. Should I stick to drinking one or the other or is it best to just keep drinking both? I’m only asking because I consume these beverages every single day and the ritual of drinking these are a big part of my life.

    5) You suggested that I take my B-complex only Monday, Wednesday, and Friday. Before I was taking one every morning. Is there scientific reasoning behind only supplementing with this a few times a week versus every day?

    Thank you very much for taking the time to read all this! I look forward to hearing back from you over the upcoming weeks.

    Mike

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hi Mike.

    You are too kind with your comments....

    And WOW the questions you have put forth are highly highly intelligent, but would require a whole book to answer accurately. That being said I will take one question at a time and answer them in stages as expeditiously as possible. I will enjoy answering them immensely. Stay tuned. (They will be answered in sequence, not too technical but as always with referencing, and logic.)

    Dhia Aldoori

    ReplyDelete
  10. To M.F.:
    I have started to answer your questions here http://thepillarsofhealth.blogspot.com/2012/04/why-im-fan-of-copper.html
    with the first post about copper.
    Enjoy and comment.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Hey, I found this and thought you might find it interesting...

    "Is the sugar in maple syrup healthier than white sugar?

    The sugar in maple syrup is sucrose with small amounts of glucose and fructose sugar. White sugar is sucrose. There is no direct scientific evidence that maple syrup is healthier than white sugar. Diabetics need to treat maple syrup and sugar as they do other sugar products. Because it is a less refined sugar, maple products contain minerals, antioxidants, and other compounds that have been shown to have health advantages in other foods."

    Source: Cornell Sugar Maple
    Research & Extension Program
    http://maple.dnr.cornell.edu/FAQ.htm

    Another: http://www.nnyagdev.org/maplefactsheets/cmb%20202%20chemistry%20of%20maple%20syrup1.pdf

    ReplyDelete
  12. Hello,
    I can't find references in the text. Were they removed?
    Thanks,
    Yacht

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Unfortunately when I first wrote the "Pillars", I was pressed for time and hence didn't put the references at the end of each writing or chapter. I will rectify this down the road. Meanwhile most of the references are located here: http://thepillarsofhealth.blogspot.com/2008/04/references-in-alphabetical-order.html

      Delete
  13. Hello Dr Aldoori,
    I was hoping to download and print the E-Book but the link to download it is not functioning. I was also wondering if you've published this as an E-Book on mobile apps like Issuu etc.
    Thank you for taking the time to read this.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. No, sorry, I have not published it as an E book. I am planning on doing so after updating/revising it. Time permitting.
      Downoading now functional. Sorry about that.

      Delete